Net vs Gross Calories Burned and Why Treadmills Overstate
Gross calories are everything your body burns during a workout, including what it would have burned at rest. Net calories are only the extra. For a 70 kg person walking 30 minutes at a moderate pace, gross is about 140 kcal and net is about 103 kcal, so the gross figure is about 36% higher.
What is the difference between net and gross calories?
Your body uses energy every minute just to keep you alive. Breathing, circulation and body temperature all cost something, even when you sit still.
When you exercise, that background cost does not stop. A gross figure adds it to the cost of the movement and reports the total. A net figure removes it and reports only what the exercise added.
Neither number is wrong. They answer different questions. Gross answers "how much energy did my body use during this half hour?" Net answers "how much more did I burn because I exercised instead of resting?"
Why does the difference matter for weight?
Because the resting part was going to be burned anyway. It is already counted in your daily baseline, the figure often called TDEE or maintenance calories. If you are not sure what that covers, see what TDEE is.
If you add gross exercise calories on top of that baseline, you count the resting energy twice. Over a week of workouts, the double count adds up.
Only the net figure tells you how far a session moved your day. That is the number to use when you compare exercise with food.
How is each one calculated?
Both use MET values. One MET is the energy cost of resting. The 2024 Adult Compendium of Physical Activities lists MET values for hundreds of activities, including about 3.8 for walking at a moderate pace.
The standard formulas are:
- Gross kcal = MET × 3.5 × weight in kg ÷ 200 × minutes
- Net kcal = (MET − 1) × 3.5 × weight in kg ÷ 200 × minutes
The only difference is the "− 1". That one MET is the resting energy.
Can you show a worked example?
Take a 70 kg (154 lb) person who walks for 30 minutes at a moderate pace, 3.8 MET.
Gross: 3.8 × 3.5 × 70 ÷ 200 = about 4.65 kcal per minute. Over 30 minutes that is about 140 kcal.
Net: 2.8 × 3.5 × 70 ÷ 200 = about 3.43 kcal per minute. Over 30 minutes that is about 103 kcal.
The gap is about 37 kcal. That is what this person would have burned sitting on the sofa for the same 30 minutes. The treadmill display says 140, but the walk only added 103.
How big is the gap for different activities?
The gap is always one MET, so it matters more when the activity is gentle. The table shows 30 minutes for a 70 kg person.
| Activity | MET | Gross kcal | Net kcal | Gross is higher by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Easy walking, about 4 km/h | 3.0 | about 110 | about 74 | about 50% |
| Moderate walking, 4.5 to 5.5 km/h | 3.8 | about 140 | about 103 | about 36% |
| Stationary bike, about 60 W | 5.0 | about 184 | about 147 | about 25% |
| Elliptical, moderate | 5.0 | about 184 | about 147 | about 25% |
For a 90 kg (198 lb) person the same 30 minutes of moderate walking is about 180 kcal gross and about 132 kcal net. The percentages stay the same, since both numbers scale with weight.
Easy walking shows the problem most clearly. A third of the gross figure is energy you would have used doing nothing.
All of these are estimates that vary between people. If you have a health condition, are pregnant or take heart medication, plan your activity with a professional.
Why do treadmills and watches show the higher number?
Many cardio machines report the total energy used during the session, which is a gross figure. It is a legitimate measurement, and it is also the bigger and more encouraging one.
Wearables differ. Some show an "active" figure and a "total" figure for the same workout. The active figure is closer to net, and the total is gross. It is worth checking which one your device puts in large type.
Gross versus net is not the only source of error. A machine that never asked for your weight is assuming one. Holding the handrails reduces the work you do while the display carries on as before. Wrist sensors estimate from heart rate and movement, and the result can be off in either direction.
Which number should I use?
Use net when you are comparing exercise with food, or working out how much activity balances a day. Use gross only if you want the total energy for the session and are not adding it to a daily baseline.
If your device only shows gross, you can convert it. Multiply by (MET − 1) ÷ MET. For moderate walking that is 2.8 ÷ 3.8, or about 0.74. So 200 kcal on a treadmill display at walking pace is about 147 kcal net.
Burnby uses net calories throughout, which is why its minutes can look longer than other calculators. When it tells you how many minutes of walking, stationary bike or elliptical balance your day, it counts only the extra energy. You can get your own number to see how that works out for your weight.
For net figures across body weights, see how many minutes of walking it takes to burn calories.
FAQ
Are treadmill calorie counts accurate?
They are rough estimates, and they usually show gross calories. For moderate walking, the gross figure is about 36% higher than the extra calories the walk added, and it may be further off if the machine does not know your weight.
What are net calories burned?
Net calories are the energy an activity adds on top of what you would have burned at rest in the same time. They are calculated by subtracting one MET, the resting cost, from the activity's MET value.
Should I eat back the calories my watch says I burned?
Be careful with that. If the figure is gross, part of it is already counted in your daily baseline, so eating all of it back overshoots. Using the active or net figure is the safer choice.
Why does Burnby show fewer calories than my treadmill?
Burnby reports net calories and labels them as estimates. Your treadmill most likely reports gross calories, which include resting energy you would have used anyway.